Recent surveys have shown that at
least 1 in 3 people will use complementary or alternative therapies at
some time during their life. Every year more than 1 in 10 will visit a
complementary therapist for one of six named therapies: acupuncture,
osteopathy, chiropractic, herbal medicine, hypnotherapy or homeopathy. GP
practices and primary care increasingly provide their patients with access
to therapies such as these.
A new information pack on
complementary medicine is launched during a special exhibition at the
House of Commons sponsored by the All-Party Group for Complementary
Medicine. It has been produced by the Department of Health in
collaboration with the NHS Alliance, the National Association of Primary
Care and the Foundation of Integrated Medicine. The initiative follows the
joint NHS Alliance–Exeter University conference on complementary
medicine held last September, and a Department of Health study into the
issues involved in the commissioning of complementary therapies by PCGs
A booklet designed for clinicians
will shortly be provided to every GP practice. A more detailed pack will
be sent to all Primary Care Groups and Trusts. Both are designed to inform
clinicians and managers, and provide a resource for making sensible and
locally sensitive decisions about commissioning the six complementary
therapies that are most often provided in the NHS. The documents are also
available on-line.
They provide information on six
individual therapies including details of relevant qualifications and the
bodies responsible for the registration of medically-qualified and
non-medical practitioners. For each therapy information is given on what
conditions would benefit most from treatment. A pragmatic view has been
taken of examples of best evidence of effectiveness.
For example, there is reasonable
evidence supporting the use of acupuncture for low back pain but it is not
more useful than placebo acupuncture for smoking cessation. However, the
placebo effect is substantial and leads to immediate cessation in about
35% of all patients.
Homeopathy is used for a wide
variety of conditions. It has been shown to be particularly effective in
conditions where there is an allergic component, such as asthma and hay
fever. It is also used where drug treatments are poorly tolerated or
contra-indicated, in chronic disease and for those who suffer repeated
episodes of acute illness.
Similar information is provided on
osteopathy, chiropractic, hypnotherapy and aromatherapy, together with
advice on referring patients to complementary practitioners and employing
therapists in local practices.
Dr Michael Dixon, Chairman of the
NHS Alliance and one of the principal collaborators in producing the pack,
is giving evidence today to the Enquiry into Complementary Medicine
currently being carried out by the House of Lords Select Committee on
Science and Technology. No longer regarded as the province of charlatans
and the deluded, there is an increasing interest in complementary
therapies from politicians and health service managers as well as
clinicians.
Speaking at the House of Commons
today, Dr Dixon said:
"Complementary therapies
tend to offer a very patient-oriented system of treatment. They focus on
the whole person. Medical treatments, however, tend to be disease-oriented
and so relatively impersonal. The patient may feel he or she is on a
conveyor belt, or even taking part in a cattle market.
"I sometimes hear colleagues
talk disparagingly about the placebo effect of complementary therapies.
What is that but the self-healing process of the individual patient?
Primary care clinicians should be open-minded about the benefits of
complementary medicine whether based on a western scientific rationale or
not. The combination of mind and body that produces self-healing must be
encouraged."
Michael Fox, of the Foundation of
Integrated Medicine said:
"We hope this information
pack will prove to be a valuable resource for primary care clinicians and
managers. A publication of this nature is long overdue and we are very
pleased indeed that it has been produced in collaboration with the
Department of Health, the NHS Alliance and the NAPC."
"This guide offers the
opportunity for the NHS to begin to explore how therapies can become truly
complementary rather than alternatives to orthodox medicine," added
Dr Peter Smith, Chairman of the National Association of Primary Care.
"For too long the proliferation of therapies and qualifications has
confused GPs and the public, to the detriment of the credibility of many
practitioners. As a practitioner myself of acupuncture and homeopathy, I
welcome the clear, sensible descriptions and endorsements provided. At
last we have an authoritive and informative guide to help PCGs and GPs
understand and advise on the place of complementary therapies."
Primary Care clinicians and managers
will have the opportunity to find out more at the NHS Alliance conference
on Complementary Medicine and PCG/Ts, to be held at the Royal Society of
Medicine on 26th September. For details, see the Alliance
website: www.nhsalliance.org
ends
For more information, contact:
Pat Goodall, NHS Alliance Press Office
Tel: 01246 410707
mobile: 07718 162976
pager: 07654 617978
Notes to editors:
- The principal collaborators in
producing the pack are:
- Dr Joel Bonnet, until recently
Senior Registrar in Public Health at the NHSE;
- Dr Michael Dixon, Chairman of the
NHS Alliance;
- Clive Parr of the National
Association of Primary Care, and
- Michael Fox, Chief Executive of
the Foundation of Integrated Medicine.
- Both documents are available
on-line from at: www.nhsalliance.org,
www.doh.gov.uk www.fimed.org
or www.primarycare.co.uk
- The more detailed pack provided
to PCGs and PCTs gives examples of existing models of provision and
describes the current level of NHS provision of complementary
therapies. It is expected that this will be of interest to managers as
well as clinicians. Sources of further information are also summarised
and listed.